Ethical Sports Takes

We hear the same thing every time a superstar decides to leave a team.

“He wasn’t loyal.”

Fans get angry. Jerseys get burned. Players get called ring chasers. Suddenly years of great performances are forgotten because an athlete decided the best move for his career was somewhere else.

But I have one question. Why are athletes expected to show loyalty to organizations that would replace them tomorrow if it made the team better?

Loyalty in professional sports sounds great. In reality, I think it is completely overrated.

Teams Will Always Do What Is Best for Them

Professional sports are businesses. That might not sound romantic, but it is the truth.

A franchise can love a player. Fans can adore him. His jersey can fill the stadium every Sunday or every night. But if management believes trading or releasing that player makes the organization better?

They will do it.

And honestly, they should.

Teams are trying to win championships. General managers are paid to improve their rosters, not reward players forever because of what they accomplished five years ago.

My problem is not with teams operating that way. My problem is expecting players to operate differently.

If organizations are allowed to make business decisions, players should be allowed to make career decisions.

At the End of the Day, It Is Still a Job

Sometimes we forget this because professional athletes make millions of dollars and play a game for a living.

But at the end of the day, playing professional sports is still a job. You just get paid a hell of a lot more.

What does a regular person do when they are no longer happy with their employer?

THEY LEAVE.

Maybe another company offers them more money. Maybe they have a better opportunity somewhere else. Maybe they do not like management. Maybe they simply need a change.

Nobody expects an accountant to spend their entire career at the same firm because the company gave them their first opportunity. So why do we expect an athlete to do it?

If another organization offers a player more money, a better situation or a greater opportunity to accomplish his career goals, why shouldn’t he leave?

Teams treat sports like a business. Players should be allowed to do the exact same thing.

Players Have Short Careers

This is something fans sometimes forget. Professional athletes do not get unlimited opportunities.

An NFL player’s career can disappear because of one injury. An NBA superstar might have only a handful of seasons where he is physically capable of competing at his absolute peak.

Why should that player waste those years somewhere he no longer believes gives him the best opportunity to succeed?

Maybe he wants a championship. Maybe he wants a bigger role. Maybe another organization is willing to pay him more. Maybe he simply wants a different situation.

Those are all legitimate reasons to leave.

Loyalty Can Actually Hurt a Legacy

Here is where sports conversations become especially strange.

We criticize players for leaving teams to pursue championships. Then when their careers end, we criticize them for not winning enough championships.

Think about how ridiculous that can become.

A superstar stays with one organization for years despite poor roster construction and gets praised for being loyal. Then we compare him with another superstar and say:

“Yeah, but how many rings did he win?”

So what exactly was he supposed to do? Stay loyal to a situation that was not working and then get punished historically because he did not win enough?

You cannot demand loyalty from players and then use the consequences of that loyalty against them.

And Fans, Become a Bandwagon If You Want

And this does not only apply to players. Loyalty goes both ways.

Sports are supposed to be entertainment. You are supposed to enjoy watching them. So I have never understood why some fans act like you are automatically required to support the team closest to where you were born.

Imagine someone saying:

“Well, I’m from New York, so I automatically have to be a Jets fan.”

Why?

Why would you voluntarily sign yourself up to be miserable every Sunday for years just because of your ZIP code?

If watching another team makes football more enjoyable for you, watch that team. Become a bandwagon fan.

Who cares?

If you started watching basketball because you loved Stephen Curry, root for Golden State. If Tom Brady made you fall in love with football, maybe you followed him from New England to Tampa Bay. If you simply like a team’s players, uniforms, history or style of play, support them.

You do not need to submit paperwork proving that your grandparents lived within 30 miles of the stadium.

Obviously, sticking with a struggling team for years and eventually watching them win can be incredibly rewarding. There is something special about saying you were there through all of it.

But if someone does not want to do that? That is completely fine too.

Sports are entertainment, not an obligation. Nobody should spend years making themselves miserable just so another fan can certify them as “loyal.”

Staying With One Team Is Still Special

None of this means loyalty is meaningless.

There is something incredibly special about seeing an athlete spend an entire career with one franchise. When a player becomes synonymous with one uniform, one city and one fanbase, it creates a connection that bouncing between teams simply cannot replicate.

The same applies to fans who stick with their team through decades of losing and finally get to experience that championship. That deserves respect.

But loyalty should be viewed as something special, not something required.

Loyalty Has to Go Both Ways

This is really what the entire conversation comes down to.

Teams will do what is best for themselves. Players should be allowed to do what is best for themselves. And fans should be allowed to watch whichever team makes them actually enjoy the sport.

Stay with one franchise for 20 years if that is what you want. Leave after five if you believe there is a better opportunity somewhere else.

Root for your hometown team your entire life. Or become the biggest bandwagon fan on Earth.

It is sports. Have fun.

Loyalty can make sports incredibly special. But it should never make sports miserable.

If you enjoyed the article, make sure to like and subscribe to Ethical Sports Takes for more opinions, rankings and sports content.